The Orange Gamble: Should Ruto Seek Re-election on an ODM Ticket?

0
The High Court has ruled that Ruto’s announcements reserving 20pc of affordable homes for teachers and police cannot override allocation rules under the Affordable Housing Act.
President William Ruto. Image/ Courtesy

By CPA Enock Monari,

The political arithmetic may look attractive, but the president risks weakening the UDA party and the regional coalition that brought him to power.

In 2022, William Ruto beat Raila Odinga by 233,211 votes. He polled 7,176,141 against Odinga’s 6,942,930. Any accountant would call that a razor-thin margin on a very large base.

The President now speaks of winning in 2027 by up to three million votes. That ambition explains why a once unthinkable question is being asked openly: should he defend his seat on an Orange Democratic Movement (ODM) ticket?

The question gained weight last week. On 2 November, Nairobi Governor Johnson Sakaja left the United Democratic Alliance (UDA) for ODM, saying the late Raila Odinga had told him to make the move.

A day later, former Senate Majority Leader Samuel Poghisio left KANU for ODM to pursue the West Pokot governorship.

ODM has already declared that it will not field a presidential candidate and will back Dr Ruto. Its deputy leader, Kisii Governor Simba Arati, has long urged the President to rejoin the party and carry its flag.

The orange ticket is a tempting shortcut. It can also be a wrong move. Dr Ruto stands to gain more from a written, registered UDA-ODM coalition than from trading his party’s colours for ODM’s.

The case for the switch is real and deserves fair hearing. An ODM nomination certificate is once again valuable currency.

Politicians are crossing over because they believe the orange symbol wins seats, particularly in Nyanza, where the party’s following has been formidable for two decades.

A single ticket would also end the bruising contests between UDA and ODM aspirants in the lake region and give both parties one national platform.

Look closer at the traffic, however. Most of it flows out of UDA. Sakaja is the biggest name, but others have followed, including Silas Jakakimba, who has rejoined ODM from the ruling party to contest Suba North.

Every such move strengthens a partner and hollows out the President’s own machine. A party that keeps losing its elected leaders and aspirants risks becoming a vehicle with no engine at the grassroots. Switching tickets would complete that hollowing.

Nor do defectors carry their voters with them by default. ODM insists its nominations will be competitive, and chairperson Gladys Wanga has said that anyone with the members’ support will fly the flag.

Poghisio, for one, walks straight into a crowded West Pokot contest. Open primaries produce losers, and losers take their supporters elsewhere. The movement of elites is not the movement of votes.

The harder question is how much of ODM’s base is still ODM’s to transfer.

A TIFA survey released in May reportedly found 73 per cent of ODM supporters backing the Linda Mwananchi movement led by Nairobi Senator Edwin Sifuna, against 24 per cent for the camp aligned with the party leadership.

That movement now plans to become a party of its own and has floated Sifuna for the presidency. Odinga’s 6.9 million votes never belonged to a symbol.

With him off the ballot, nobody can assume they will follow an endorsement, least of all in Western Kenya, where loyalties are already contested.

Then there is Mount Kenya, where the President can least afford losses. In July, Rigathi Gachagua’s Democracy for Citizens Party (DCP) took the Ol Kalou by-election with 35,440 votes, a landslide over the UDA candidate.

UDA Secretary-General Hassan Omar maintains that Deputy President Kithure Kindiki remains the party’s running mate, and MPs from Mt Kenya East have warned the President against dropping him.

A move to the orange ticket would read in the region as a retreat from the 2022 bargain. It would also hand Gachagua his easiest campaign message.

UDA’s own organs matter too. Its National Executive Committee mandated the President to set up structured engagement with ODM. That is a mandate to build an alliance, not to abandon the party.

An alliance preserves UDA’s identity and gives its members a stake in the outcome; a change of ticket concedes that the ruling party cannot stand on its own.

The strongest objection is that a coalition is weaker than a single party. Kenyan coalitions have a long record of collapsing over the sharing of power, and a Ruto on the orange ticket would signal full commitment to ODM voters.

But a common ticket does not settle the sharing. It only moves the fight inside one party, where the losers have fewer protections.

The two parties have reportedly already agreed on a single campaign committee and a joint campaign account.

The machinery of a coalition is half built. What is missing is the written deal.

The ask is therefore specific. President Ruto, as UDA party leader, and ODM leader Oburu Oginga should conclude a written pre-election coalition agreement before party nominations begin.

It should settle the running mate and the formula for sharing positions, and it should be deposited with the Registrar of Political Parties as the law requires. Voters are entitled to see the terms of a coalition that is asking for their support.

A switch that wins over Nyanza’s officials but loses Ol Kalou’s voters would give the President a bigger map and a smaller margin. In 2027, the colour on the ballot will matter less than the strength of the coalition behind it.

The Author, CPA Enock Monari, is a Managing Partner at Burmon Global Consulting Group.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here