The EU introduced the tariffs, which could reach as high as 35%, after an investigation determined that China’s state subsidies were giving Chinese carmakers an unfair advantage over European automakers.
On Tuesday, EU Trade Commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis defended the move as “proportionate and targeted,” stressing that it followed an extensive investigation intended to protect Europe’s domestic industries.
“We welcome competition,” Dombrovskis said, “but it must be underpinned by fairness and a level playing field.”
Yet, the decision has exposed fault lines within the EU, with Germany and Hungary voicing concerns over possible retaliation from Beijing.
China’s commerce ministry sharply criticized the tariffs as politically motivated and vowed on Wednesday to take “all necessary measures” to safeguard its industries.
Chinese officials emphasized that the decision would hinder global trade and impact the broader EV sector, an area of rapid growth in both Europe and China.
The ministry stated that China “does not agree with or accept” the EU’s decision, asserting that it is prepared to defend Chinese companies through all legal avenues, including WTO mechanisms.
In Germany, the auto industry has issued a stark warning, with the country’s largest automotive association labeling the tariffs a threat to international trade.
Hildegard Müller, president of the German Association of the Automotive Industry, described the tariffs as a “step backward for free global trade” and warned of potential job losses across Europe.
Volkswagen, one of the hardest-hit companies, has echoed this sentiment, arguing that tariffs will do little to bolster the European car industry’s competitiveness against an increasingly aggressive Chinese market.
The tariffs will add to the existing 10% import duty on Chinese electric vehicles and impact both Chinese brands and foreign companies manufacturing in China, such as Tesla, which will face an additional 7.8% tariff.
Chinese auto giant Geely will encounter an 18.8% increase, while SAIC, another major EV producer, is subject to the maximum 35.3% duty.
The decision was met with divided opinions within the EU. While France, a strong supporter of the tariff plan, welcomed the protective measures, they were opposed by several member states.
The EU car industry, employing 14 million people, has been lobbying for safeguards as it grapples with Chinese competition and a sluggish economy.
French Finance Minister Antoine Armand praised the move as a pivotal step toward defending Europe’s automotive sector.
However, German manufacturers are worried about the ripple effects on their already-strained operations; Volkswagen recently announced plans to close multiple factories in Germany and cut jobs amid rising competition.
The EU’s dispute with China over EVs is just one piece of a broader trade puzzle.
Brussels has ongoing investigations into Chinese subsidies for solar panels, wind turbines, and other green technologies.
Meanwhile, Canada and the United States have imposed even steeper tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles in recent months, reflecting shared concerns about subsidized competition from China.
Both sides have expressed a willingness to negotiate an alternative solution, including establishing minimum pricing for Chinese cars entering the EU market, which could offset the need for tariffs.
Dombrovskis indicated that the EU is open to a compromise, provided it ensures fair competition and complies with WTO standards.
However, Beijing’s swift WTO complaint, along with hints at possible retaliatory tariffs on European exports like brandy, dairy, and pork, underscore the potential for the dispute to deepen.
With both the EU and China aware of the high stakes, this tariff clash may be a defining moment in their broader trade relationship as they seek to balance competition with cooperation.