NAIROBI, Kenya — The High Court has temporarily stopped Chief Justice Martha Koome and the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) from publishing individual performance data for judges and judicial officers in the upcoming State of the Judiciary and Administration of Justice Report (SOJAR).
Justice David Mburu issued conservatory orders on Thursday, November 19, barring the respondents from releasing the information as an addendum, appendix or in any other form ahead of the report’s scheduled launch on Friday, November 20.
The judge certified an application filed by Duncan Kariuki as urgent, warning that publishing the data before the dispute is heard could render the pending petition and application academic.
“I am satisfied that the application and the pending petition raise fundamental constitutional and legal questions and that the intended publication of the data, if so published, shall render the petition and pending application academic and otiose,” Justice Mburu ruled.
The orders are temporary and will remain in force as the court considers the challenge to the proposed disclosure.
Why the publication is being challenged
Kariuki is opposing the planned release of individual performance figures, arguing that the Judiciary has not established a clear regulatory or policy framework governing how the information should be collected, verified, interpreted and published.
In his petition, he warns that releasing the figures without proper context could expose judges and judicial officers to public ridicule, cyber harassment and doxxing.
He also argues that the disclosure could undermine judicial independence, the dignity and welfare of judicial officers, and public confidence in the administration of justice.
The petitioner questions the accuracy and completeness of the information, saying that excluding data from some courts could result in unfair comparisons and discrimination among judicial officers.
He maintains that performance accountability is necessary but insists that the Judiciary should first establish clear rules to ensure the information is presented fairly.
“The petitioner is not opposed to the publication of the said data in principle but is only craving for formulation of the modalities of the publication for the data to have the basis for a sensible interpretation thereof,” he states in his affidavit.
Dispute over judicial accountability
The court battle follows the Judiciary’s announcement in July 2026 that it intended to begin publishing individual performance reports for judges and judicial officers.
The initiative was presented as part of efforts to strengthen transparency, accountability and public confidence in the courts.
The Judiciary said the reporting process would involve verification, validation and approval of performance returns before publication. It also outlined a reporting window for court stations to compile and certify their figures.
However, Kariuki argues that the proposed publication lacks an adequate legal foundation and could expose judicial officers to unfair scrutiny.
His petition invokes constitutional protections relating to equality, human dignity, labour rights, judicial independence and the mandate of the JSC.
He has also cited the Judicial Service Act, Data Protection Act and Computer Misuse and Cybercrimes Act, alongside international principles governing judicial conduct and independence.
The dispute also raises questions about the respective responsibilities of the JSC, the Chief Justice and the Chief Registrar of the Judiciary in managing and communicating judicial performance information.
What happens next?
Justice Mburu directed the respondents and interested parties to file their responses within seven days of service of the application.
The matter will return to court on December 1, 2026, for further directions.
The orders mean the JSC and the Chief Justice cannot release the individual performance data in the scheduled report while the interim restrictions remain in force.
The case now places the Judiciary’s push for greater public accountability against concerns about the legal safeguards, accuracy and potential consequences of publishing individual judicial performance figures.




