Why Two KRA Officials Were Acquitted in Fraud Case

Date:

The Milimani court found that investigators had failed to prove the officials personally stole money or manipulated electronic tax records, despite suspicious transactions being linked to their KRA usernames.

NAIROBI, Kenya — Two Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) officials have been acquitted in a long-running cyber fraud case after a Milimani court found that the prosecution had failed to establish their personal involvement in the alleged theft and manipulation of tax records.

The officials, Lucy Katilo Wamwandu and Kenneth Opere Riaga, were cleared of charges of stealing by a person employed in the public service and abuse of office, respectively.

In her judgment, Chief Magistrate Carolyne Nyaguthii Mugo ruled that investigators had not provided sufficient evidence to connect either official directly to the alleged offences.

The case arose from claims that hackers and other suspects interfered with KRA’s electronic systems between March 2015 and March 2017, allegedly resulting in the loss of approximately Sh3.9 billion.

Court finds no proof of Sh1 million theft

Katilo had been accused of stealing Sh1 million from the tax authority after approximately Sh1 billion in tax penalties was allegedly removed through a username linked to her in KRA’s legacy system.

However, the magistrate found that the prosecution had failed to establish that Katilo personally received or appropriated the money.

The court noted that investigators had not identified the specific funds allegedly stolen, their source or how they came into her possession.

The prosecution also failed to produce witnesses who allegedly paid her the money, bank transactions or financial records linking her to the alleged theft.

Katilo had told the court that her responsibility was to implement penalty waivers approved by the station manager and that she did not independently authorise the decisions.

The magistrate further observed that the prosecution had not produced the relevant waiver applications, registers and internal memoranda to demonstrate that the transactions had been processed unlawfully.

The court also considered evidence that KRA’s systems had experienced security breaches involving malware and key-logging programmes capable of capturing employees’ login credentials.

Katilo had testified that she discovered her credentials remained active even after she had travelled to Germany for leave and reported the matter to her station manager in April 2016.

However, investigators failed to establish who had introduced the malware or who physically operated the computers involved in the suspicious transactions.

The magistrate ruled that linking an employee’s username to a transaction was not, on its own, sufficient to prove that the employee had stolen public money.

Missing electronic evidence weakens case against second official

Riaga had faced an abuse-of-office charge over allegations that he falsified KRA electronic records between March 1, 2015 and March 1, 2017.

The prosecution alleged that approximately Sh63 million in tax penalties had been waived through a username attributed to him.

However, the court found that investigators had not produced sufficient documentary or electronic evidence identifying the specific records allegedly falsified by Riaga.

The relevant electronic devices were not produced in court, while forensic evidence did not conclusively establish that he was the person who operated the computers when the alleged alterations occurred.

The investigating officer also conceded that he had not established that Riaga personally waived the taxes.

The prosecution further failed to produce a laptop allegedly recovered from the fourth floor of Times Tower, where investigators suspected some of the activities had taken place.

Riaga had told the court that he worked on the second floor and questioned why investigators had not examined CCTV footage to establish who accessed the fourth floor and operated the laptop.

The magistrate found that the prosecution had not proved that he personally falsified the records, instructed another person to do so or knowingly facilitated the alleged manipulation.

The court emphasised that criminal responsibility must be established against each accused person individually.

How the Sh3.9 billion KRA case unfolded

The case dates back to 2017, when investigators began examining suspicious activity detected within KRA’s electronic systems.

The investigation reportedly followed the discovery of unauthorised computer activity, prompting a multi-agency probe involving the Directorate of Criminal Investigations, the National Intelligence Service and the ICT Authority.

The prosecution called 15 witnesses, including KRA employees, cybersecurity officers, forensic examiners and police officers.

The wider case involved 11 suspects accused of participating in an alleged scheme to interfere with the tax authority’s systems.

In earlier proceedings, nine suspects were acquitted of the substantive charges they faced after the court found that the prosecution had failed to establish a case against them. All 11 accused persons were also acquitted of conspiracy to commit a felony after the court found insufficient evidence of a meeting of minds or coordinated action.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

spot_imgspot_img

Trending

More like this
Related

GTA 6 Launches Worldwide After 13-Year Wait as UK Players Enter Vice City

Rockstar Games’ long-awaited Grand Theft Auto VI has arrived...

Children’s Lies May Signal Healthy Brain Development, Experts Say

Children who deny breaking a toy, hide stolen sweets...

[DETAILS] Koech’s KCSE Police Claim Contradicts KNEC Security Records

NAIROBI, Kenya — Belgut MP Nelson Koech has praised...

Naivas Takes Top Supermarket Spot in 2026 Brand Ranking

NAIROBI, Kenya — Naivas has been ranked Kenya’s leading...